Rare Tail Mystery Combo
- A Legendary Pairing: A colossal centerpiece joined by two of Maine’s most coveted tails — a feast worthy of myth and memory.
- Rarity Hints: One is so rare it represents less than 1% of the annual catch. The other is Maine’s largest legal catch, prized for their rich, meaty perfection.
- Ocean-Born Brilliance: Hand-harvested from icy North Atlantic waters, where sustainability isn’t a buzzword — it’s a way of life.
- Flash-Frozen at Peak Glory: Each tail is preserved in its prime using nitrogen technology — sealing in ocean sweetness and tenderness.
- Here, Then Gone: This combo exists in limited supply. When these tails vanish, so does your chance to taste Maine’s rarest treasures.
Description
The Mystery Rare Tail Combo
Not every legend reveals itself right away. Some stories are meant to unfold — one shell at a time.
This week’s Rare Tail Tuesday isn’t just an offer, it’s an enigma. A pairing of tails so exceptional, they almost never appear together in the same box. One is a behemoth — the kind of tail that could silence a room. The others? Regal in stature, meaty in presence, and Maine’s largest legal catch.
You could call it balance. You could call it excess. We call it mystery well played.
One tail was hand-harvested by Maine’s most seasoned lobstermen from the icy, deep waters of the Gulf of Maine — where only the strongest and most pristine lobsters thrive. The other, a little further south where revolutionaries once tossed tea in the harbor. Both were flash-frozen at peak sweetness using nitrogen technology, preserving the taste of the ocean at its most powerful moment.
This is the kind of feast that turns dinner into a story — and the story into a tradition.
What to Expect:
All colossal centerpieces. A moment of culinary awe that only happens when the sea's rarest treasures meet your table.
Serving Suggestion:
Feeds 3–6 people depending on appetite. Best enjoyed when you’re ready to surprise, delight, and create your own legend.
Shipping Information
We’ve carefully selected the best materials and shipping services to ensure your order arrives fresh, intact, and ready to impress—from our dock to your doorstep.
- Delivery Days: We ship Monday-Friday for delivery Tuesday-Saturday. Saturday delivery costs $25 extra and may not be available in all areas.
- Live Lobster & Fresh Seafood:
Ships via Priority Overnight or Next Day Air. Choose your delivery date at checkout. FREE SHIPPING on orders over $200! - Frozen Lobster & Appetizers:
Ships via 2nd Day Air or Ground (based on your location) within 1-4 business days. FREE SHIPPING on orders over $200! Order by 5:59 AM EST to ship within 1-4 days. - Order Deadlines:
For same-day shipping on Live Lobster & Fresh Seafood, order by 9:00 AM EST. We recommend ordering early for special occasions. - Carriers & Timing:
We ship with UPS, FedEx, GLS, and OnTrac. Delivery times may vary, especially during holidays or to rural areas. Some addresses may receive deliveries as late as 8-9 PM. For restricted-access addresses, contact customer service before ordering. - Saturday Deliveries:
Available in most areas with a $25 fee at checkout (subject to verification).
Pro Tip: Plan ahead for the freshest Maine seafood delivered to your door!
Preparation Instructions
Lobster at Home? Easier Than You Think!
Preparing lobster at home doesn’t have to be intimidating. In fact, we’ve made it easier than ever. Every order comes with detailed prep tips to ensure you’re set up for success. Whether you’re grilling tails, steaming live lobsters, or creating a lobster roll feast, our website is packed with step-by-step guides, expert tips, and mouthwatering recipes.
Want product-specific prep advice? No problem! Here’s everything you need:
- Lobster Tails Prep & Cooking Guide >
- Live Lobsters Cooking Guide >
- Dinner Party Ready Lobster Rolls >
- VIEW ALL >
From dock to doorstep, we’ve thought of everything so you can focus on what matters most—creating unforgettable moments around the table.
Rare Tail Mystery Combo
- A Legendary Pairing: A colossal centerpiece joined by two of Maine’s most coveted tails — a feast worthy of myth and memory.
- Rarity Hints: One is so rare it represents less than 1% of the annual catch. The other is Maine’s largest legal catch, prized for their rich, meaty perfection.
- Ocean-Born Brilliance: Hand-harvested from icy North Atlantic waters, where sustainability isn’t a buzzword — it’s a way of life.
- Flash-Frozen at Peak Glory: Each tail is preserved in its prime using nitrogen technology — sealing in ocean sweetness and tenderness.
- Here, Then Gone: This combo exists in limited supply. When these tails vanish, so does your chance to taste Maine’s rarest treasures.
Description
The Mystery Rare Tail Combo
Not every legend reveals itself right away. Some stories are meant to unfold — one shell at a time.
This week’s Rare Tail Tuesday isn’t just an offer, it’s an enigma. A pairing of tails so exceptional, they almost never appear together in the same box. One is a behemoth — the kind of tail that could silence a room. The others? Regal in stature, meaty in presence, and Maine’s largest legal catch.
You could call it balance. You could call it excess. We call it mystery well played.
One tail was hand-harvested by Maine’s most seasoned lobstermen from the icy, deep waters of the Gulf of Maine — where only the strongest and most pristine lobsters thrive. The other, a little further south where revolutionaries once tossed tea in the harbor. Both were flash-frozen at peak sweetness using nitrogen technology, preserving the taste of the ocean at its most powerful moment.
This is the kind of feast that turns dinner into a story — and the story into a tradition.
What to Expect:
All colossal centerpieces. A moment of culinary awe that only happens when the sea's rarest treasures meet your table.
Serving Suggestion:
Feeds 3–6 people depending on appetite. Best enjoyed when you’re ready to surprise, delight, and create your own legend.
Shipping Information
We’ve carefully selected the best materials and shipping services to ensure your order arrives fresh, intact, and ready to impress—from our dock to your doorstep.
- Delivery Days: We ship Monday-Friday for delivery Tuesday-Saturday. Saturday delivery costs $25 extra and may not be available in all areas.
- Live Lobster & Fresh Seafood:
Ships via Priority Overnight or Next Day Air. Choose your delivery date at checkout. FREE SHIPPING on orders over $200! - Frozen Lobster & Appetizers:
Ships via 2nd Day Air or Ground (based on your location) within 1-4 business days. FREE SHIPPING on orders over $200! Order by 5:59 AM EST to ship within 1-4 days. - Order Deadlines:
For same-day shipping on Live Lobster & Fresh Seafood, order by 9:00 AM EST. We recommend ordering early for special occasions. - Carriers & Timing:
We ship with UPS, FedEx, GLS, and OnTrac. Delivery times may vary, especially during holidays or to rural areas. Some addresses may receive deliveries as late as 8-9 PM. For restricted-access addresses, contact customer service before ordering. - Saturday Deliveries:
Available in most areas with a $25 fee at checkout (subject to verification).
Pro Tip: Plan ahead for the freshest Maine seafood delivered to your door!
Preparation Instructions
Lobster at Home? Easier Than You Think!
Preparing lobster at home doesn’t have to be intimidating. In fact, we’ve made it easier than ever. Every order comes with detailed prep tips to ensure you’re set up for success. Whether you’re grilling tails, steaming live lobsters, or creating a lobster roll feast, our website is packed with step-by-step guides, expert tips, and mouthwatering recipes.
Want product-specific prep advice? No problem! Here’s everything you need:
- Lobster Tails Prep & Cooking Guide >
- Live Lobsters Cooking Guide >
- Dinner Party Ready Lobster Rolls >
- VIEW ALL >
From dock to doorstep, we’ve thought of everything so you can focus on what matters most—creating unforgettable moments around the table.
WILD CAUGHT
Sourced straight from the ocean, ensuring authentic, untamed flavor that you can taste. You can come to Maine and see the process in action.
SUSTAINABLY SOURCED
Responsibly harvested to protect marine life and our planet, Maine’s sustainable fishing tradition is passed down by generations of lobstermen and women.
100% ALL NATURAL
Pure seafood with no additives—just nature at its finest. Maine has been harvesting lobster naturally since the 1600s. A tradition you experience with every bite.
HAND HARVESTED
Expertly gathered by skilled hands for unmatched quality, always by hand and never by net—a tradition passed down to future farmers of the sea.
PEAK FRESHNESS
Our lobster tails are flash-frozen at its prime to lock in the freshest taste. Our live lobsters, harvested in the morning, delivered the next day.
100% ALL NATURAL
Pure seafood with no additives—just nature at its finest. Maine has been harvesting lobster naturally since the 1600s. A tradition you experience with every bite.
PROTECTING THE RESOURCES
WILD CAUGHT BY HAND, SUSTAINABLY HARVESTED
Maine lobsters are hand-harvested from small day boats & caught one trap at a time with strict requirements on size & breeding status. We’re proud to be part of this heritage.
THE FRESHEST MAINE LOBSTER
Flash Frozen At Peak Freshness, State-Of-The-Art Nitrogen Technology
Wild-caught in Maine
Sustainably Harvested by Hand
Flash-Frozen At Peak Freshness For You
Featured & Recognized By
