Seafood for Thought: The First Thanksgiving

Every November, my mailbox gets stuffed with magazines all singing the same turkey-tune. It's like they're all part of some turkey fan club! But here's what puzzles me each year as I flip through these festive pages: Where's the seafood? This itch led me on a deep dive into the culinary deep end of the first Thanksgiving, revealing a feast that was less about the turkey trot and more about the seafood shuffle.

Historical Feast: What Did the Pilgrims Really Chow Down On?

Picture this: the 1620s, Cape Cod Bay, a seafood spread that would make even the saltiest sea captain jealous. The Pilgrims and the Wampanoag weren’t just passing around turkey legs; they were likely feasting on a smorgasbord of the ocean’s bounty, playing a starring role in their survival and celebrations.

Seafood's Starring Role in the Original Thanksgiving Feast

maine lobster feast for thanksgiving posted by get maine lobster

Why did they throw this shindig called Thanksgiving? It wasn't just about celebrating a bountiful harvest but really giving thanks for making it through the year. And what was on the menu? Not just your garden-variety veggies but heaps of Cape Cod’s finest seafood, showing just how much these ocean treasures meant to their everyday feasting and feisty surviving!

Chef Mackenzie Arrington: Culinary Ambassador from Maine

Reflecting on the first state to host Thanksgiving, Maine's own Chef Mackenzie Arrington brings historical culinary practices to life. A celebrated chef and Maine Lobster Chef of the Year, Mackenzie's journey from the Culinary Institute of America to renowned kitchens embodies a modern-day homage to our culinary heritage.

Revisiting the Authentic Thanksgiving Menu

What year was the first recorded Thanksgiving in America? It was 1621, and the menu was likely rich with smoked and dried seafood, essential for the settlers' winter provisions. Today, we can draw inspiration from these early culinary practices to enrich our modern Thanksgiving traditions.

Embracing Our Culinary Heritage

This year, let's broaden our Thanksgiving palate by incorporating seafood, particularly lobster, which offers a direct link to the dietary practices of the first settlers. By doing so, we honor not just a tradition but the very spirit of Thanksgiving celebrated by those who came before us.

Download Exclusive Recipes

Inspired to blend historical authenticity with modern culinary creativity? Download our exclusive Thanksgiving Seafood Recipes booklet here: Mac's Favorite Thanksgiving Recipes and discover delicious ways to infuse your holiday feast with the flavors of the first Thanksgiving.

Conclusion: A New Thanksgiving Tradition

As we gear up for this year's Thanksgiving spread, why not throw some live lobsters and premium tails into the mix? It’s not just a nod to the first-ever Thanksgiving feast, but a way to spice up our tables with some sea-sprinkled flair! Let's dive into the holiday spirit with a splash of tradition, serving up dishes that not only taste fantastic but also sail us back to the historic tables of New England. From ocean to table, let’s cook up a Thanksgiving that's both a feast for the taste buds and a tribute to the true origins of this holiday!

Back to blog