Monthly Mystery Box

503 reviews
  • Always includes succulent lobster
  • Always feeds at least four
  • Expertly curated assortment of seasonal faves & premium provisions
  • Flash-frozen; arrives ready to thaw, cook & enjoy
  • Free Shipping; your first box ships out the next available ship date

*Please Note: Your first box will ship out the next available ship date from time of order.


Love great food and a great mystery? Good news! Due to popular demand, we've made our customer-favorite Mystery Boxes available as a monthly subscription...and you can still order as a one-time purchase, if you aren't quite ready to subscribe!

Each monthly Mystery Box features a different expertly curated assortment of seasonal favorites and premium provisions. Customers often share with us that our Mystery Boxes have introduced them to new, delicious products they may never had discovered. You know what folks really rave about, though? Our Mystery Boxes always include sweet, succulent lobster! 

Past boxes have included enormous 14-16 oz. lobster tails, sweet chili shrimp, pre-seasoned salmon on cedar plank, chocolatey Whoopie Pies and more. 

We'd love to surprise and delight you with our monthly mystery experiences. Subscribe when you're ready to dive into the fun!

Get Maine Lobster™ Promise: Our Maine lobsters are wild-caught by lobsterwo/men dedicated to preserving the sustainability of the Maine lobster industry and engage in practices that ensure its health and vitality. Each lobster is hand-selected with care and humanely by experienced lobster-handling experts and packaged with sustainable, environmentally-friendly materials.

Customer Reviews
4.9 Based on 503 Reviews
5 ★
4 ★
3 ★
2 ★
1 ★
Customer Photos
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
  • mystery box
  • tails
  • delivery
  • Lobsters
  • surprises
  • Beef Wellington
  • scallops
  • ordering
  • meat
  • crab cakes
Tammy A.
United States

Loving it

I love the surprise each month. I enjoy finding new things I may not have tried before. I loved the whoopie pies! Lobster is always delicious!

Catherine F.
United States United States

Octobers Great Mystery Box

Great selection. Always fun surprises. Love the chowder and tails.

Rowilan C.
United States United States

Worth the money

I love mystery boxes, no regrets of my subscription it’s worth my dollars. I’m thrilled what’s my next box will be. Everything that I got were good and delicious.

Karen J.
United States United States


Everything we have received has been above and beyond expectations.

Margot L.
United States United States


We ate the stuffed clams and crab cakes Tuesday night. Last night we had the Beef Wellington! It was delicious. More crab cakes and stuffed clams for next week. Lobster tails this weekend. Off to Ireland for a few weeks, I will be back in time for my anticipated October Mystery Box. Thank you all!�