First Mate's Bounty

A full table of four, start to finish.
4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
9,323 Reviews
Regular price $244.88
Regular price Sale price $244.88
  • A table of four, start to finish.
  • Straight off our wharf. No middleman.
  • This Black Friday only. Might be FridayEE.
  • If it isn’t worth the evening, we make it right.
Flash-frozen at peak freshness.
Choose arrival date at checkout.
FREE shipping at $200.
Sourced in Maine from 48 Union Wharf.

Description

A full table of four, start to finish.

The first mate runs the deck so the captain can run the boat. This crate runs the dinner so you can sit down at it. It comes in courses: something for the people who arrive early, something once they settle in, and then the part everyone came for. We won’t say what’s in it. We’ll say nobody leaves hungry.

The clues: Five things in the crate. Four tails, two sizes. Something for the early arrivals, something from the stove, and the reason everyone stayed.

Shipping Information

We’ve carefully selected the best materials and shipping services to ensure your order arrives fresh, intact, and ready to impress—from our dock to your doorstep.

  • Delivery Days: We ship Monday-Friday for delivery Tuesday-Saturday. Saturday delivery costs $25 extra and may not be available in all areas or on all Saturdays.
  • Live Lobster, Fresh Seafood, Frozen Lobster & Appetizers:
    Ships via Priority Overnight or Next Day Air. Choose your delivery date at checkout. FREE SHIPPING on orders over $200!
  • Order Deadlines:
    For same-day shipping, order by 9:00 AM EST. We recommend ordering early for special occasions.
  • Carriers & Timing:
    We ship with UPS, FedEx, GLS, and OnTrac. Delivery times may vary, especially during holidays or to rural areas. Some addresses may receive deliveries as late as 8-9 PM. For restricted-access addresses, contact customer service before ordering.
  • Saturday Deliveries:
    Available in most areas with a $25 fee at checkout (subject to verification).

Pro Tip: Plan ahead for the freshest Maine seafood delivered to your door!

Preparation Instructions

Lobster at Home? Easier Than You Think!

Preparing lobster at home doesn’t have to be intimidating. In fact, we’ve made it easier than ever. Every order comes with detailed prep tips to ensure you’re set up for success. Whether you’re grilling tails, steaming live lobsters, or creating a lobster roll feast, our website is packed with step-by-step guides, expert tips, and mouthwatering recipes.

Want product-specific prep advice? No problem! Here’s everything you need:

From dock to doorstep, we’ve thought of everything so you can focus on what matters most—creating unforgettable moments around the table.

First Mate's Bounty

A full table of four, start to finish.
4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
9,323 Reviews
Regular price $244.88
Regular price Sale price $244.88
  • A table of four, start to finish.
  • Straight off our wharf. No middleman.
  • This Black Friday only. Might be FridayEE.
  • If it isn’t worth the evening, we make it right.
Flash-frozen at peak freshness.
Choose arrival date at checkout.
FREE shipping at $200.
Sourced in Maine from 48 Union Wharf.

Description

A full table of four, start to finish.

The first mate runs the deck so the captain can run the boat. This crate runs the dinner so you can sit down at it. It comes in courses: something for the people who arrive early, something once they settle in, and then the part everyone came for. We won’t say what’s in it. We’ll say nobody leaves hungry.

The clues: Five things in the crate. Four tails, two sizes. Something for the early arrivals, something from the stove, and the reason everyone stayed.

Shipping Information

We’ve carefully selected the best materials and shipping services to ensure your order arrives fresh, intact, and ready to impress—from our dock to your doorstep.

  • Delivery Days: We ship Monday-Friday for delivery Tuesday-Saturday. Saturday delivery costs $25 extra and may not be available in all areas or on all Saturdays.
  • Live Lobster, Fresh Seafood, Frozen Lobster & Appetizers:
    Ships via Priority Overnight or Next Day Air. Choose your delivery date at checkout. FREE SHIPPING on orders over $200!
  • Order Deadlines:
    For same-day shipping, order by 9:00 AM EST. We recommend ordering early for special occasions.
  • Carriers & Timing:
    We ship with UPS, FedEx, GLS, and OnTrac. Delivery times may vary, especially during holidays or to rural areas. Some addresses may receive deliveries as late as 8-9 PM. For restricted-access addresses, contact customer service before ordering.
  • Saturday Deliveries:
    Available in most areas with a $25 fee at checkout (subject to verification).

Pro Tip: Plan ahead for the freshest Maine seafood delivered to your door!

Preparation Instructions

Lobster at Home? Easier Than You Think!

Preparing lobster at home doesn’t have to be intimidating. In fact, we’ve made it easier than ever. Every order comes with detailed prep tips to ensure you’re set up for success. Whether you’re grilling tails, steaming live lobsters, or creating a lobster roll feast, our website is packed with step-by-step guides, expert tips, and mouthwatering recipes.

Want product-specific prep advice? No problem! Here’s everything you need:

From dock to doorstep, we’ve thought of everything so you can focus on what matters most—creating unforgettable moments around the table.

WILD CAUGHT

WILD CAUGHT

Sourced straight from the ocean, ensuring authentic, untamed flavor that you can taste. You can come to Maine and see the process in action.

SUSTAINABLY SOURCED

SUSTAINABLY SOURCED

Responsibly harvested to protect marine life and our planet, Maine’s sustainable fishing tradition is passed down by generations of lobstermen and women.

100% ALL NATURAL

100% ALL NATURAL

Pure seafood with no additives—just nature at its finest. Maine has been harvesting lobster naturally since the 1600s. A tradition you experience with every bite.

HAND HARVESTED

HAND HARVESTED

Expertly gathered by skilled hands for unmatched quality, always by hand and never by net—a tradition passed down to future farmers of the sea.

PEAK FRESHNESS

PEAK FRESHNESS

Our lobster tails are flash-frozen at its prime to lock in the freshest taste. Our live lobsters, harvested in the morning, delivered the next day.

100% ALL NATURAL

100% ALL NATURAL

Pure seafood with no additives—just nature at its finest. Maine has been harvesting lobster naturally since the 1600s. A tradition you experience with every bite.

THE GULF OF MAINE

COLDER WATER.
SWEETER MEAT.

Maine lobster tails harvested from cold water grow slower and tastes sweeter — that's biology, not marketing.

The Gulf of Maine is among the coldest waters on earth for Maine lobster tails, and every lobster tail starts there. You can taste the latitude.
READ MORE

THE PROPRIETORS' MARK

HAND-GRADED.
FLASH-FROZEN AT PEAK FRESHNESS.

Maine lobster tail is graded by hand against The Proprietors' Mark — shell integrity, size accuracy, meat density — then nitrogen-flash-frozen within hours of harvest.

The Maine lobster tails that don't measure up don't ship. What arrives is the Maine lobster tail we'd serve at our own table.

THE CENTERPIECE

BIG TAILS.
BIG NIGHTS.

A 14-ounce lobster tail doesn't need a special occasion.
It is the special occasion.

This is the cut that turns dinner into the night people talk about for years.
READ MORE

Featured & Recognized By

4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
Based on 9,323 reviews
98%would recommend these products
Slide 1 selected
9,323 reviews
  • BV
    BRENDA V.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    10 Prime 4-5 oz Lobster Tails
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1 hour ago
    The Best !!!

    These tails were the best I have had in a long time. Two tails are perfect for one person. Full of flavor and meat !!! Will definitely order again.

  • DH
    David H.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Regal 12-14 oz Maine Lobster Tail
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    11 hours ago
    Titan tail

    Cut in half after thawing in the fridge with paper towel for a few days. Put it on grill cut in half shell side down. Put butter with my garlic on it and it was delicious. Sautéed kallettes with elm oyster added later as a side. Wow

  • SE
    Stacey E.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Buy Two 10-12 oz Lobster Tails, Get Four 4-5 oz Tails FREE
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    11 hours ago
    OMG

    This was the best deal! I made the 10-12oz lobster tails and they were so sweet and tender. Looking forward to having the 4-5oz lobster tails which are a very nice size

  • DF
    Debra F. H.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Special - Classic (4-5oz) Maine Lobster Tails 20-Pack + Free Shipping
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Yesterday
    I now have 50 tails for Thanksgiving

    It may sound excessive but my 40 guest look forward to this every year. We start with lobster tails on butter lettuce, a spoonful of grandmas potato salad a small cup of you lobster bisque and a petite glass of sherry to pour in like we do in Charleston SC with she crab soup.

    The we go to the carving tables for turkey ham and ribeye and fixings. We start with your lobster it’s the best

  • RR
    Richard R.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Grandeur 6-7 oz Maine Lobster Tail
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Yesterday
    10 grand tails

    My 10 tails arrived on time and without controversy. I split the larger tails, pull the meat out of the shell then insert back in the shell. I baste in white wine, lemon juice, butterand garnish with sliced lemons and old bay. Takes only 8-9 minutes to bake at 375. When serving, remove lobster from the shell and add a filet and baked potatoes. Since the dinner is special, I typically serve with champagne. Outstanding!