Captain's Mystery Box

495 reviews
  • Always includes succulent lobster + exclusive extra goodies
  • Always feeds at least four to six
  • Upgraded take on monthly Mystery Box with extra special goodies
  • Flash-frozen; arrives ready to thaw, cook & enjoy
  • Free Shipping; your first box ships out the next available ship date

*Please Note: Your first box will ship out the next available ship date from time of order.


An upgraded take on our monthly Mystery Box! Not only does our Captain's Mystery Box always includes succulent lobster and premium seasonal selections, we also pack it with exclusive extra goodies with an at least $50 value.

Just like our monthly mystery boxes, our Captain's Mystery Box experience arrives brimming with an assortment of seasonal favorites and premium provisions curated each month.

Our customers often remark that our Mystery Boxes have introduced their households to new, delicious products they may never had discovered. You know what folks really rave about, though? Our Mystery Boxes always include sweet, succulent lobster!

Past boxes have included enormous 14-16 oz. lobster tails, sweet chili shrimp, pre-seasoned salmon on cedar plank, chocolatey Whoopie Pies and more. We'd love to surprise and delight you with our monthly mystery experiences...including extra goodies (at least $50 value!) with our Captain's Mystery Box.

Subscribe when you're ready to dive into the fun!

Get Maine Lobster™ Promise: Our lobsters are wild-caught by lobsterwo/men dedicated to preserving the sustainability of the Maine lobster industry and engage in practices that ensure its health and vitality. Each lobster is hand-selected with care and humanely by experienced lobster-handling experts and packaged with sustainable, environmentally-friendly materials.

Customer Reviews
4.9 Based on 495 Reviews
5 ★
4 ★
3 ★
2 ★
1 ★
Customer Photos
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
  • lobster tails
  • shrimp
  • mystery box
  • tails
  • Everything
  • clams
  • items
  • quality
  • price
  • dinner
Michele B.
United States

Captain’s Mystery Box

Just got our second subscription in and we LOVE IT! Besides being fun to get (and I love surprises), everything is exceptional quality and boy, do you get a great selection for your money! Great job!! Can’t wait for our next surprise dinner! This is just GREAT!!!

Joseph Z.
United States United States

First time buyer

Very prompt shipping to mid-eastern PA. Arrived frozen with lots of ice remaaining. Made the lobster tails over labor day - very good for m 1st try.

Tracey T.
United States United States


This by far is the best lobster I have tasted in a very long time! Very sweet and tender, no need for butter for me, just a little lemon and I was good to go. The 8oz tails were so big and so easy to cook. I will definitely buy it again and again! Thank you for coming into my life :)

Mandy S.
United States United States

Arrived Frozen

I was worried about the lobsters still being frozen with the Louisiana heat but they arrived frozen! We defrosted and grilled some for dinner the following night and they were excellent!

Cathy C.
United States United States

Best Mystery

Loved everything shipped in this “ delicious” box. The selections in this box will be the highlight at the end of a long summer day. You will not be disappointed !