10 Creative Sauces That Instantly Elevate Maine Lobster Tails

Mark Murrell

If you've ever had Maine lobster tail, then you're already aware of how much of a treat it can be to eat it by itself. Adding the proper sauce to your lobster tail can take your lobster night to a new level. Here's the deal: while melted butter is probably the most sought-after, your lobster tail can do better than melted butter. With dipping sauces for lobster tail, you can enhance sweetness, add texture, and even wow your guests with a novel, bold flavor combination.

In the blog, we will explore various methods of pairing sauces with the meaty flavor of lobster tails. 

The Go-To Classics But With a Twist

Below are some classics to go about. Make sure you don’t miss out on these:

#1 Brown Butter & Lemon Zest

There's something special about nutty brown butter that becomes even better with the bright and fresh zing of lemon zest. This combination is perfect for broiled lobster tails when you want the sweet flavor of the lobster meat to shine, but you still wish to have a vibrant butter sauce to use as a backbone.

#2 Garlic Herb Butter with a Touch of Smoked Paprika

This isn’t a simple garlic butter recipe because we add warmth. The smokiness of the smoked paprika adds character to the sauce and depth, but doesn't attempt to overshadow the delicate meat of the lobster. 

#3 Tarragon Shallot Beurre Blanc

French-inspired and luxurious, this buttery sauce with a ton of creaminess offers a "fine dining at home" experience! This sauce is perfect for romantic dinners or if you just want to impress yourself. 

Skewered Get Maine Lobster tails lined on blue tray, ready for grilling or butter-basted broiling

Sweet & Spicy Combos to Wake Up Your Palate

Just leave yourself here to glance at your perfect combo for the next lobster on your palate:

#4 Mango-Habanero Drizzle

This exciting combination of sweet and two styles is perfect for grilled lobster tails. Sweet mango provides a tropical nectar-like sweetness, and fiery habanero lends some long-lasting heat, providing a sauce that teases without deterring. It’s sunshine in a spoon that brings about the right spice balance.

#5 Honey Sriracha Dipping Sauce

It's a flavor explosion in a sticky, spicy mixture! The golden sweetness of honey pairs unbelievably well with the garlicky, spicy sriracha for a dip you can’t stop putting into your mouth and wanting more. This is your go-to dipping sauce for steamed or pan-seared tails when you want to hit that beautifully bold and bright flavor profile, don’t forget the depth of umami!

#6 Cajun Remoulade with a Hint of Dijon

This is a delicious Southern-inspired sauce with layers of tang, spice, and creaminess. You've got the best of both worlds: Dijon mustard for gourmet flair, and Cajun spices for warmth. It's bold with good zest, and you could elevate nearly any lobster tail just with a single spoonful. It will turn it from casual to memorable!


Maine lobster claw coated in Momofuku Wasabi Yuzu sauce with visible herbs and creamy texture.

Momofuku Wasabi Yuzu Sauce (16oz)

$14.99
Shop now
Plated Maine lobster rolls and lobster tails with asparagus, lemon wedges, and butter on a marble table.

LOBSTER ROLLS & TAILS BUNDLE for 4

$199.99
Shop now

Globally Inspired Sauces for the Adventurous Lobster Lover

When you eat lobster, the taste remains on your tongue. Here are some globally inspired sauces to provide richness to your taste buds, so they are:

#7 Thai Coconut Curry Butter

This Thai-inspired sauce shells your lobster meat in layers of flavor. It is rich, aromatic, and full of soul. The richness of coconut milk mixes nicely with warm curry spices, offering a deeply comforting bite with every forkful. An absolute treat when served with steamed tails and fluffy fresh jasmine rice, this creates cravings for more!

#8 Japanese Ponzu with Fresh Grated Ginger

A careful balancing act between citrusy brightness and savory umami, this ponzu sauce is nothing if not eye-opening. It has freshly grated ginger, which provides a spicy kick, making it the perfect refreshing complement to lightly poached chilled lobster salads or tail meat. You can also throw grated daikon and/or a splash of yuzu in there for some added excitement.

#9 Chimichurri with Cilantro & Lime

Lively, herbaceous, and bursting with flavor, chimichurri is a zesty counterpoint to lobster's sweetness. Fresh cilantro, parsley, garlic, and lime juice easily slice through the fattiness of grilled or baked tails. It's an electric green treat that makes your taste buds prance.

#10 Spicy Harissa Yogurt Dip

This creamy tart Greek yogurt dip and smoky, spicy North African harissa are full of bold flavor. It has a nice cool heat, refreshingly cooling on the palate, while the rich, warming spice takes time to emerge. Wonderful with grilled lobster tails, this dip is exciting and tastes layered.

Chef pours chilled tomato gazpacho over plated Get Maine Lobster medallions, cucumber curls, and fresh herbs.

FAQs 

     1. What is the best dipping sauce for lobster tails?

It depends on how you want to eat and how well your lobster tails are cooked. Brown butter lemon, garlic herb butter, and Thai curry are fabulous sauces. There are many dipping sauces to explore on our menu page.

    2. What wine pairs well with lobster tail and garlic butter?

A crisp Chardonnay or buttery Viognier goes together wonderfully. If you use a spicy sauce, try Riesling or a rosé served with a nice chill.

    3. How do you make the lobster tail more flavorful?

Begin with the best Maine lobster tails. Use a fun sauce, serve with vivacious sides, then hit it with a squirt of lemon or herbs.

Your Lobster Tail, Your Flavor Adventure

In short, the right sauce can take your Maine lobster tail from decadent and nutty buttery brown deliciousness to bright chimichurri and incredibly exotic and spicy Thai coconut curry. They are not just sauces; they’re flavor journeys in the making.

So next time it’s lobster night, don’t settle for just a bowl of melted butter. Get creative and serve your guests (or yourself) a flavor high with every bite.

Get your tails, grab your sauce ingredients, and let the flavor journey begin.

Back to blog